Skip to main content

UX and research · Advanced · 17 min

Run a jobs-to-be-done switch interview

By Padding · Updated 18 Nov 2026
A video call or quiet room, a notes app, a spreadsheet and a sheet of paper or whiteboard · November 2026

You will have a dated timeline of one person's switch to a new way of booking appointments, from first thought to first use, and a forces diagram that sets out the pushes, pulls, anxieties and habits behind it.

On this page

Ask people why they chose something and they give you a tidy reason: "the app is more convenient". It is true, and it is useless for design. Convenient compared with what? Since when? Convenient enough to put up with what? The real reasons sit in the weeks before the choice: a call that rang out, a friend who showed them the app at a bus stop, a worry about whether a booking made online really counts.

A switch interview recovers those weeks. Instead of asking about opinions, you rebuild one real change, step by step, in the order it happened. You treat the participant's memory like an incident you are reconstructing: dates, places, who was there, what they tried and dropped. Once the story is laid out, you sort what drove it into four forces. Two push the person towards a change (the trouble with the old way, the appeal of the new one) and two hold them back (worry about the new way, comfort in the old one).

This tutorial uses Larkfield Clinic, a fictional community clinic that has launched an appointment booking app. The team wants to know why some patients moved from phoning reception to booking in the app, and why others tried it and went back. You will interview one patient, Tolu, who switched about two months ago. You end with a dated timeline of her switch and a forces diagram for it.

Run this after you are comfortable with basic interviewing. The technique asks you to push gently for detail people do not expect to be asked for, and that only works once neutral follow-ups are a habit.

Step 1 · Pick one switch and recruit for it

A switch interview studies one decision, not a person's general behaviour. Write the switch as a "from, to" sentence before you recruit, so you can screen for it:

From: booking Larkfield appointments by phoning reception. To: booking them in the Larkfield app.

Then set the recruiting rules:

  • Recent. The first real use of the new way happened within the last three to six months. Older than that, and people tell you the reasons they have settled on, not the ones they had.
  • Real. They have actually done it, not just downloaded the app. A booking they made and attended counts.
  • Their own decision. They chose to switch. Someone whose employer moved them, or whose old option closed, has a different story.

Recruit a second group if you can: people who started to switch and went back (downloaded the app, then phoned anyway). Their anxieties and habits are usually the most useful findings. For this tutorial, start with one participant who completed the switch.

Check it worked

Your plan has a one-line "from, to" statement, and your participant's screener answers show the date of their first use of the new way falls inside your window, that they completed at least one booking with it, and that the change was their own choice.

Step 2 · Prepare a timeline sheet, not a question list

A switch interview has no script of questions. It has a shape to fill. Make a sheet (paper, or a spreadsheet with one column per stage) with six stages from left to right:

  1. First thought. The first time they noticed the old way was not quite working.
  2. Passive looking. They were aware something better might exist, but were not searching.
  3. Event that made it urgent. Something happened that turned "one day" into "now".
  4. Active looking. They compared options, asked people, tried things.
  5. Deciding. The moment they committed, and what they gave up or put up with.
  6. First use and after. The first booking with the new way, and whether it met what they hoped.

Under each stage, leave room for: date or rough time, place, people involved, what they did, and what they felt. Add a line at the top for the switch statement and the participant code (for example P04), not their name.

You will not fill the stages in order. People remember the decision first and the early doubts last. The sheet lets you see the gaps while you talk.

Check it worked

You have a blank sheet with six labelled stages, each with space for when, where, who, did and felt, plus a header line with your switch statement and a participant code. There is no list of questions on it.

Step 3 · Anchor the interview on the moment of first use

Open with consent and recording, then go straight to the most concrete moment: the first time they used the new way. It is the easiest to recall and gives you a fixed point to work backwards from.

Ask for the scene, not the opinion:

  • "Take me back to the first time you booked in the app. Where were you?"
  • "What time of day was it? What were you doing just before?"
  • "Who was the appointment for?"

Tolu remembers it was a Sunday evening, on her sofa, booking a blood test for her mother. That detail matters: it was outside reception's hours, and it was for someone else.

Small physical details (the room, the device, the weather) are not small talk. Each one pulls more memory with it, and they help you spot when a participant has started summarising instead of remembering. When the answers turn general ("I usually just..."), bring them back to the scene: "On that Sunday, what happened next?"

Check it worked

The "First use" column of your sheet has a date or close estimate, a place, the device, who the booking was for, and at least one feeling in the participant's words, all from the first ten minutes.

Step 4 · Work backwards to the first thought

From the first use, step back one stage at a time. The aim is to find when the old way first started to bother them, which is often months before they did anything about it.

Useful moves:

  • Step back. "Before that Sunday, when did you first hear about the app?" "Before that, when did phoning start to feel like a problem?"
  • Ask for the last time. "Think about the last time you phoned reception before you switched. What happened on that call?"
  • Bracket the date. If they cannot place something, give them anchors: "Was that before or after the school holidays? Was it cold?"
  • Find the event. Look for the thing that made it urgent. "Was there a point where you thought, I'm not doing that again?"

For Tolu, the story comes out like this. Last spring she spent twenty minutes on hold during her lunch break and gave up (first thought). Over the summer she saw a poster about the app in the waiting room but did nothing (passive looking). In September her mother needed a series of blood tests, and Tolu had to book each one around her own job (event). A neighbour showed her how she booked her son's check-up in the app (active looking). She downloaded it but did not book for a week, because she was not sure an app booking would appear on reception's list (deciding).

Write each fact into its stage as you hear it, with the participant's own words in quotes where you can. Expect gaps and contradictions. Note them, and come back to them before the end rather than correcting the participant mid-story.

Check it worked

Every one of the six stages on your sheet has at least one dated or roughly dated entry, and you can point to a specific event in the third column that made the switch urgent. Any stage you could not fill is marked with a question mark, not left blank.

Step 5 · Probe for what held them back

The pushes and pulls come out on their own. What held people back usually does not, because once they have switched they no longer feel it. Ask about it directly, and ask about the old way with respect: it worked well enough for years.

  • "Was there anything that made you hesitate before your first booking?"
  • "What were you worried might go wrong?"
  • "What did you like about phoning reception?"
  • "Is there anything you still do the old way?"

Listen for two different kinds of answer:

  • Anxiety about the new way. Fears and unknowns: "Will the receptionist know I've booked?" "What if I pick the wrong service?" "Can I cancel without ringing?"
  • Habit of the old way. Comfort, routine and relationships: "Sandra on reception knows my mum." "I could ask a question while I was on the phone."

Tolu says she phoned once after her first app booking, just to check it was there. That is anxiety in action, and it is a design lead for the Confirm and Booked screens. She also says she still phones for anything that needs a doctor's advice, which is a habit worth keeping, not a problem to fix.

Check it worked

Your notes contain at least two quoted worries about the new way and at least one thing the participant valued about the old way. If you only have praise for the app, you have not got there yet.

Step 6 · Close by replaying the timeline

Before you finish, read the timeline back in order, in two or three minutes: "So last spring you gave up on a call in your lunch break, in summer you saw the poster, in September your mum's tests started..." Ask the participant to correct you.

Replaying does three jobs. It catches dates you got wrong. It fills the question marks you left. And it often prompts a detail the participant had forgotten: Tolu adds that the neighbour also told her the app sends a reminder the day before, which mattered because her mother forgets appointments.

Thank them, stop the recording, and fill any remaining gaps from the recording the same day while it is fresh.

Check it worked

You have marked each correction the participant made on your sheet, and the number of question marks is lower than before the replay. The sheet reads as one story from left to right without jumping back in time.

Step 7 · Sort what you heard into a forces diagram

Draw a plus sign on a page to make four boxes. Put the old way on the left and the new way on the right. The top two boxes push towards the switch; the bottom two hold it back:

  • Top left, push of the situation. Problems with the old way. "Twenty minutes on hold in my lunch break."
  • Top right, pull of the new way. What the new way promises. "I can book on a Sunday night." "It reminds us the day before."
  • Bottom right, anxiety about the new way. "Will reception see my booking?" "What if I choose the wrong test?"
  • Bottom left, habit of the old way. "Sandra knows Mum." "I can ask a question on the call."

Go through your timeline sheet and copy each relevant entry into one box, in the participant's words, with the stage it came from in brackets: "Twenty minutes on hold, gave up (first thought)". If an entry fits two boxes, choose the one that matches what it did in the story: did it move her forward or slow her down?

Then write one sentence under the diagram that says why this switch happened when it did. For Tolu: "Booking repeated tests for her mother around her job made the phone queue unbearable, a neighbour showed her the app could book out of hours, and she switched once she saw an app booking did reach reception, though she still phones when she needs advice."

The forces diagram from one interview is a hypothesis, not a finding. Run five to eight interviews for the same switch and compare diagrams. Forces that turn up again and again are what to design for. Anxieties that recur are often the cheapest wins: one line on the Booked screen ("Reception can see this booking") can address a worry that sent people back to the phone.

Check it worked

Your page has four labelled boxes with the old way on the left and the new way on the right, at least two quoted entries in each box, each tagged with its timeline stage, and a one-sentence summary under the diagram that names the event that made the switch urgent.

Next steps

Need this done for you?

Padding does this work for growing companies, from the first diagnosis to a system that keeps working.

Digital Transformation

Get new tutorials

New tutorials, about twice a month.